Sunday, October 2, 2022

By This You Will Know Them--By Their [Harm]: Introduction

 Don't let Christian men and boys stumble; cover up, was the message we heard every Spring in youth group as summer neared and the heat made everyone a bit antsy to strip off layers of clothing. Spaghetti straps were out, as were any shirts that showed your belly button when you raised your hands. Shorts must be lower than your fingertips, and as only Old Navy sold shorts that had a 7 inch in-seam at the time, most of us teen girls just braved the heat wearing pants or capris. Two pieces, of course, were absolutely out of the question. So were speedos, though honestly, no youth group guy that I knew at the time owned or would even consider owning such an article of clothing.

At the time, the intention of these talks was for us to consider how we can honor God through how we dress. While there is room for debate, I really do believe that these talks resulted from a desire to uphold biblical truth and emphasize inner beauty versus outer beauty.  I do not believe, at least where I grew up, that any man ever talked about modesty with the intent to shame women or teen girls or blame them for men's lack of self-control. But there were unintended consequences to the way in which these talks were presented.

I remember feeling incredibly guilty the first time a random man at the soccer field whistled at me. I must have been wearing something immodest. I must have been walking in an inappropriate way because of course it was a woman who made the man stumble, or so was implied by the modesty talks. As certain parts of my body developed in very obvious ways, I found it difficult to find shirts that fit my small shoulders and my not-so proportionate chest, and because I was obviously making all the high school boys at school stumble by wearing shirts that fit my shoulders (but not the rest), I decided I'd better wear XL and XXL T-shirts. At least then, no boy would stare at my chest instead of looking at my eyes when I talked to him.

And when, at the age of sixteen, I was accosted at a local drugstore, and was dangerously close to being kidnapped and raped, I blamed myself for being too friendly or flirtateous. Or, I contemplated, maybe my XL Vacation Bible T-shirt was immodest and I should have gotten an XXL T-shirt instead.

Looking back on it, the notion was absolutely laughable. I was swimming in that T-shirt. I was drowning in the scrub pants and, except for having a draw string, could have easily walked out of my drawers. There was no way on earth I could have looked more modest. But I believed that all sexual harassment that I experienced from 12 years old well into my early twenties was my fault because it was implied in those one-sided modesty talks.

I share my story not to cast blame but rather, to illustrate how the church, even well-intentioned, can reinforce harmful messages and hurt people even within their own walls. And unlike me, droves upon droves of people have left the church because of this unaddressed, often unacknowledged hurt. The kicker is that this hurt comes from those who are supposed to be known by their love! Throughout the next few months, I hope to explore topics such as mourning and loss, toxic masculinity, counseling, narcisissm in the church and the Mars Hill podcast, and more topics concerning the church and wounds. My goal of this blog series is three-pronged: 

To my friends who would not touch church with a nine-foot pole, that you might find comfort that not all church-goers approve of how you and those you know have been hurt, and that your hurt is valid,

To my hurting church friends, that you would know that you are not alone in your hurt, you are not alone in your weariness, and you are not alone in desiring the church to acknowledge hurt and make changes, 

And to my not-hurting church friends, that you would listen with an open heart to the stories and issues where the church got it wrong, mourn with those who are hurting, acknowledge the sins of the church, and create bridges to minister to the hurting world.

It took years, counselors, scripture, and godly friends and leaders in my life, all acknowledging my pain and pointing me to Christ, the loving Jesus, to heal from the unintended wounds of the modesty culture. But not everyone is so fortunate as I.

**Want to suggest topics of discussion or contribute writing to this slightly random passion project I've started after years of writer's block? PM me!


1 comment:

  1. Nicely said, Kim. You have a brilliant mind, heart, and a wonderful willingness to go deep inside and then express it with care and compassion.

    ReplyDelete